What to do if your landlord refuses to fix things?

Question

Accepted Answer

When a landlord fails to address necessary repairs, it creates not only a breach of the lease agreement but often a violation of the local "implied warranty of habitability." This legal doctrine mandates that landlords must provide a living space that is safe, sanitary, and fit for human habitation. When your landlord ignores requests for repairs, you must transition from casual communication to a formal, documented legal strategy to protect your rights and ensure your living conditions meet the required standards.

1. The Power of Documentation
The most critical step in any landlord-tenant dispute is establishing a "paper trail." Verbal requests are rarely sufficient if a dispute escalates to a housing court or a mediation board.

Written Notices: Send all repair requests via certified mail with a return receipt requested. This provides legal proof that the landlord received your notification. 
   Detailed Records: Keep a chronological log of every interaction. Note the date and time of the initial request, follow-up calls, and any responses received. 
   Visual Evidence: Take high-resolution photographs and videos of the damage or broken appliance. If the issue involves mold, pests, or structural damage, these visuals are essential for local health inspectors to evaluate the severity of the situation.

2. Verify Local Habitability Standards
Before taking drastic action, you must understand your specific local and state laws. "Habitability" is not subjective; it is defined by building codes. Generally, these codes cover:
   Structural Integrity: Roofs, walls, and foundations that are weather-tight.
   Plumbing and Sanitation: Access to hot and cold water, working toilets, and sewage disposal.
   Electrical Safety: Properly functioning wiring and outlets.
   Heating and Ventilation: Adequate heat during winter months and safe air quality.
   Pest Control: Freedom from infestations that pose health risks.

If the issue is merely cosmetic—such as faded paint or a slightly scratched floor—it likely does not qualify as a breach of habitability. Focus your energy on issues that threaten health or safety.

3. Escalation Tactics: Reporting to Authorities
If a landlord continues to ignore formal requests, the next step is to involve external regulatory bodies.

Local Code Enforcement: Contact your city’s building department or code enforcement office. They can dispatch an inspector to your property. If the inspector finds violations, they will issue a formal citation to the landlord, legally compelling them to make repairs within a specified timeframe.
   Health Department: If the issue involves sewage leaks, mold, or vermin, the local health department is often more effective than code enforcement. These agencies have the authority to condemn a property if it is deemed unsafe, which is a powerful motivator for a landlord to act quickly.

4. Legal Remedies: Withholding Rent and "Repair and Deduct"
In many jurisdictions, tenants have specific legal remedies if the landlord remains non-compliant. However, proceed with extreme caution here, as these actions carry the risk of eviction if not handled perfectly.

Repair and Deduct: Some states allow you to hire a professional to perform the repair and deduct the cost from your next month's rent. You must usually provide the landlord with a final notice stating your intent to do so, and you must keep all invoices and receipts.
   Withholding Rent: In some regions, you may legally withhold rent and place it into an escrow account until the repairs are completed. Never simply stop paying rent without consulting a local tenant's rights attorney. In many jurisdictions, withholding rent without a court order or legal escrow process constitutes grounds for eviction, regardless of the repair status.

5. Seeking Legal Counsel
If the repairs are extensive or if you face retaliation—such as the landlord threatening eviction or raising the rent immediately after you complain—you must seek professional legal assistance.

Legal Aid Societies: Many cities have organizations dedicated to providing free or low-cost legal advice to tenants.
   Tenant Unions: Joining a local tenant union can provide you with collective bargaining power and access to resources that individual tenants often lack.
   Civil Litigation: In extreme cases, you may be entitled to "rent abatement," where a court orders the landlord to return a portion of the rent you paid while the property was in a state of disrepair.

Final Considerations: Retaliation Protections
Most jurisdictions have strict anti-retaliation laws. It is illegal for a landlord to evict, harass, or penalize a tenant for exercising their right to request repairs or reporting a violation to a government agency. If you believe your landlord is retaliating against you, document every instance of harassment, as this will be vital evidence in your defense.

Always prioritize your safety. If the property becomes truly unlivable—such as a total loss of heat in sub-zero temperatures or an active electrical fire hazard—do not wait for the landlord. Seek temporary housing and consult with an attorney immediately regarding the potential for constructive eviction or lease termination.